Google
Se afișează postările cu eticheta rules. Afișați toate postările
Se afișează postările cu eticheta rules. Afișați toate postările

U.S. appeals judges quiz lawyers on rules for patenting software

miercuri, 22 mai 2013

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Lawyers squared off on Friday over U.S. rules for granting patents for software, or if software should be patented at all, in arguments in a case closely watched by Google Inc, Facebook Inc and other technology companies.

The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit heard arguments in the case, which involves whether patents for a computerized system for exchanging financial obligations are valid. The case has drawn wide interest because it could help determine parameters for software patent protection.

Disagreement was apparent among the 10 judges on the panel, and experts said they expected a divided decision, which could land the case before the U.S. Supreme Court.

The case began in 2007 when Alice Corp of Melbourne, Australia, sued CLS Bank International for patent infringement. Alice is owned in part by National Australia Bank Ltd.

CLS, which runs a foreign-exchange settlement system, argued that the Alice patents were invalid because they were nothing more than an abstract idea.

Under patent law, an abstract idea - such as the idea of a self-driving car - cannot be patented but the engineering that creates a self-driving car can be patented.

Mark Perry, the attorney who argued for CLS Bank, said that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office initially rejected one patent as too abstract but did approve it after Alice Corp re-wrote it to add the use of a computer.

But in the case of at least one of Alice's claims, an impatient Judge Kim Moore strongly disagreed. "Wow! This is so far from ... an abstract idea!" she said, referring to a portion of one patent.

Adam Perlman, the attorney who argued for Alice Corp, said that the patent should be held valid because a machine performs the function.

But Judge Timothy Dyk pressed on the question of whether the patent was abstract and whether it was obvious. An idea that is an obvious, small improvement is not considered patentable.

Referring to a system of tallying trades done over the course of a day, he suggested that it may be impossible to do such work without infringing a patent.

Patent experts at the hearing expected a divided ruling.

"I think everyone walked out of the room with the thought that there's a real difference of opinion from those judges," said Erika Arner, a patent attorney with Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner LLP, who is not involved in the case.

In July, a panel of the appeals court agreed with Alice in a 2-1 decision.

Google, Dell Inc and Facebook filed a friend-of-the-court brief criticizing the decision, arguing that patents like Alice's do not innovate enough to deserve patent protection. LinkedIn Corp, Twitter and others agreed.

International Business Machines Corp, on the other hand, filed a brief saying most software inventions qualify for patent protection. IBM, which has topped the list of U.S. patent recipients for 20 years, cautioned the court against creating a strict rule that would further limit protection.

The case comes after two Supreme Court decisions involving similar issues of patent eligibility.

In Bilski v. Kappos, the high court found in 2010 that a business-method patent for guarding against investment risk was an abstract idea and could not be patented. Last March, in Mayo v. Prometheus, the court ruled that a company could not patent a diagnostic process involving blood tests because observations about natural phenomena cannot be protected.

The case is CLS Bank International et al v. Alice Corporation Pty Ltd, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, No. 11-1301.

(Reporting By Diane Bartz and Erin Geiger Smith)


View the original article here

Read Post | comentarii

Japan, China need "rules of game" to avoid clash: Abe adviser

miercuri, 23 ianuarie 2013

TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan and China need "rules of the game" to keep a feud over tiny islands from escalating into a military clash, an adviser to Japan's prime minister said on Friday, as a ruling coalition partner prepared to visit Beijing in search of better ties.

Sino-Japanese ties chilled sharply after Japan bought the disputed islands in the East China Sea from a private Japanese citizen last September.

China scrambled two J-10 fighters last week in the area after two Japanese F-15s followed a Chinese military aircraft, which China said was on a "routine patrol".

Japan has sent up fighter jets several times recently to intercept Chinese planes near the islands, called the Senkaku by Japan and the Diaoyu by China.

Both sides have also sent patrol vessels to the area.

"We need some rules of the game. We have to discuss preventative measures," Shotaro Yachi, a former senior diplomat now advising Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on foreign policy told Reuters in an interview.

Yachi said he was very concerned about a possible unintended clash.

"During the Cold War, the United States and the Soviet Union had such 'rules of the game' to avoid a possible conflict. We can learn a lesson from their experience," he said.

Abe, who returned to the premiership after a five-year gap following his Liberal Democratic Party's (LDP) election win last month, has taken a tough stance in the row over the islands, vowing not to negotiate.

The dispute, which has coincided with a U.S. "pivot" in diplomatic and security focus to Asia, is hurting business ties between Asia's two biggest economies, creating pressure for some resolution.

COALITION PARTNER REACHING OUT

In a sign of a possible bid to reach out to China, Abe's coalition partner, Natsuo Yamaguchi, leader of the smaller, more dovish New Komeito party, is scheduled to visit China next week - perhaps carrying a message from the prime minister.

"There must be a tacit understanding between Mr. Yamaguchi and the prime minister for seeking improved bilateral ties," Yachi said. LDP Vice President Masahiko Komura is also planning a China trip, though no dates have been set.

Still, a formula for resolving the dispute remains elusive, despite suggestions that the matter could somehow be "shelved" as historians say the two countries agreed to do decades ago.

"The situation now is that their government ships come to the adjacent zone and Japan's territorial waters and government airplanes invade Japan's airspace," Yachi said.

"We don't want to 'shelve' this situation."

On Friday, Abe wound up a trip to Vietnam, Thailand and Indonesia, part of a push for stronger ties with Southeast Asia to help counterbalance China's growing influence.

Japan is also talking to its key ally the United States about revising 15-year-old guidelines on defense cooperation while planning a make-over of its own long-term basic defense policy and bigger defense spending.

Yachi said some on the Chinese side were thinking in a "realistic and rational" way, so there was hope the two countries could engage. At the same time, a lack of transparency had left Tokyo guessing just what Beijing intends.

"We need to hedge. Maybe China will not go along with that (realistic and rational) policy, so we have to prepare.

"We have no intention to 'encircle' them, but if they come, we will respond. If they want to occupy the Senkaku islands, we have to respond. If they use military force, we have to respond effectively."

(Editing by Robert Birsel)


View the original article here

Read Post | comentarii

Don't delay new bank rules too long, Asia urges Europe

marți, 27 noiembrie 2012

HONG KONG/BRUSSELS (Reuters) - Asian financial leaders warned Europe on Tuesday to limit any delay in stricter banking rules to months not years, fearing the United States' decision to shelve the controversial new global regime could derail it completely.

Europe is preparing to follow the United States in postponing the introduction of the Basel III reforms, EU sources told Reuters, and the delay could last six months or even longer if diplomats and lawmakers fail to break the deadlock.

"The fact is that the U.S. and euro zone are the most important regions where Basel III should have been implemented," Anand Sinha, deputy governor of the Reserve Bank of India, told a Thomson Reuters Pan-Asian regulatory summit in Hong Kong.

"It would have been very helpful, even if there is a delay, if the U.S. and euro zone could have indicated a definite timeline, that is not there."

The global accord hatched by central bankers and regulators in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis demands that lenders set aside more capital to cover losses such as unpaid loans. It also lays out higher standards in determining what kind of assets a bank can use to meet these capital levels.

The rules, which triple the amount of basic capital banks need to hold, are meant to be phased in over a six-year period starting in January 2013.

While a delay would be good news for small banks seeking more time to adapt, investors dislike the uncertainty.

"It's not encouraging and it won't encourage investors," said Chris Wheeler, analyst with Mediobanca. "They just want it out of the way. They want the uncertainty buried."

The European Union is struggling to agree on many aspects of the package, including what kinds of assets can be considered liquid, or available at short notice.

Sinha warned that some emerging economies could use the European delay to argue that the new rules, designed to avoid future taxpayer bailouts, should not apply to them.

Banks in the Asia Pacific region will roll out the new rules on January 1. Switzerland will also comply although its finance ministry said earlier this year that most Swiss lenders already hold enough high-quality capital to comply.

"The fact that other people aren't doing it doesn't mean that we can't," Arthur Yuen, deputy chief executive of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, told the Thomson Reuters summit.

"In Europe it's a rather complicated process, but I do hope that the deferral of the implementation will only be in terms of months not years"

EUROPEAN CONCERNS

Speaking in Paris, Michel Barnier, the EU Commissioner who oversees financial regulation, said the bloc would start introducing the reforms next year, signaling a possible delay.

"I am awaiting a reply from the U.S. to a question I asked on the reason behind these few months' delay," Barnier told a news conference. "The bulk of the Basel III architecture will be put in place within the expected time frame."

Brussels is worried that Washington's decision to ignore the deadline will put EU banks at a disadvantage to U.S. rivals.

Barnier wrote to U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke asking when Washington will introduce the capital rules and flagging the risks if the United States and Europe take different tacks, people familiar with the matter told Reuters.

"The U.S. is dragging its feet which is not fair," one said.

But privately, many officials in Brussels concede that the same is likely to happen in the 27-member European Union and that the bloc will also be forced to delay implementation, marking a further setback in efforts to reform finance.

Many lenders already meet Basel's core capital buffer rules and the secretary general of the Basel Committee, which designed the accord, told Reuters a global system would still go ahead.

"Based on the position that the U.S. and Europe have adopted, they are still saying they intend to do it. And the new requirements are relatively modest," Wayne Byres said on the sidelines of a financial sector conference in Abu Dhabi.

By standardizing EU capital rules, the law would make it easier for the European Central Bank to supervise lenders, the first step towards a banking union - a cornerstone of closer fiscal integration in the euro single currency area.

"In practical terms, it seems to be impossible to do something that is implemented by January 1, but officially that hasn't been said," a senior lawmaker in the European Parliament said.

Banks have been pushing for a delay of the new rules until the beginning of 2014, arguing that the U.S. move would put them at a disadvantage.

After months of tortuous, often late-night negotiations between the parliament and EU member states, several issues relating to the new regime remain unresolved and agreement on the broader rules has yet to be reached.

The drawn-out process of signing off a law has frustrated regulators. "This is not a good situation," said one. "They are holding themselves up for ridicule if they don't adapt on time."

(Additional reporting by Stanley Carvalho in Abu Dhabi and Yann Le Guernigou in Paris.; Writing by Carmel Crimmins; Editing by Sophie Walker)


View the original article here

Read Post | comentarii

Ireland to clarify abortion rules after woman's death

joi, 15 noiembrie 2012

DUBLIN (Reuters) - Ireland's government on Thursday pledged to clarify its abortion laws after a woman, who was denied a termination, died from septicemia in an Irish hospital.

Thousands held a candle-lit vigil outside parliament on Wednesday after news broke of the death of Savita Halappanavar, an Indian Hindu, following a miscarriage 17 weeks into her pregnancy.

Activists in Ireland, an overwhelmingly Roman Catholic country which has some of the world's most restrictive laws on abortion, say a lack of legal clarity about when termination's are justified may have contributed to her death.

"I was deeply disturbed yesterday by what Savita's husband said. I don't think as a country we should allow a situation where women's rights are put at risk in this way," Deputy Prime Minister Eamon Gilmore told parliament on Thursday.

"There is no question of equivocation. We need to bring legal clarity to this issue and that is what we are going to do," he said.

Irish law does not specify under what circumstances the threat to the life or health of the mother is high enough to justify a termination, leaving doctors to decide.

After several challenges, the European Court of Human Rights ruled in 2010 that Ireland must clarify its position.

The government has received recommendations from an expert panel after a delay of several months and would report before the end of the month, Gilmore said. Critics say the government has been dragging its heels to avoid confronting the issue.

The fact that Halappanavar is a foreign national has heightened the government's embarrassment. The story was on the front of several large Indian newspapers on Thursday.

The Indian government said on Thursday it deeply regretted Halappanavar's death. "The death of an Indian national in such circumstances is a matter of concern," a spokesman said.

Her death has dominated debate in Ireland's parliament since news of it broke on Wednesday.

Her photograph was spread across the front pages of all Ireland's major newspapers on Thursday, while editorials demanded action from politicians, who have failed for decades to clarify the law.

In 1992, when challenged in the "X-case" involving a 14-year-old rape victim, the Supreme Court ruled that abortion was permitted when the woman's life was at risk, but an earlier constitutional amendment banning abortion remains in place.

Despite a dramatic waning of the influence of the Catholic Church, which dominated politics in the country until the 1980s, successive governments have been loath to legislate on an issue they fear could alienate conservative voters.

(Additional reporting by Ross Colvin in Dehli; Editing by Louise Ireland)


View the original article here

Read Post | comentarii

Resource

Followers

 

Themes Design by Capricon Vision | Published by Templates | Powered by Blogger.com
Copyright © 2011 Politics - Some Rights Reserved