Google
Se afișează postările cu eticheta hinder. Afișați toate postările
Se afișează postările cu eticheta hinder. Afișați toate postările

Greater email privacy won't hinder law enforcement

joi, 29 noiembrie 2012

WASHINGTON (AP) — A Senate bill to protect the privacy of electronic communications won't keep federal agents from combing through your inbox if they believe a crime has been committed, legal experts say. Federal and state authorities still will have a robust set of tools to track down lawbreakers even as these officials oppose changes supported by a broad coalition of technology companies and public interest groups.

The legislation, which the Senate Judiciary Committee was expected to consider Thursday, would update a 26-year-old law by requiring police to obtain a search warrant from a judge before accessing the content of all emails and other private information from Google, Yahoo and other Internet providers. Under the current law, the 1986 Electronic Communications Privacy Act, a warrant is needed only for emails less than 6 months old.

Supporters of the bill, sponsored by Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., say the changes are necessary to overhaul a law that is outdated in an era of cloud computing, cheaper electronic storage, social networking and wireless phones. Such advances in technology have dramatically increased the amount of stored communications in ways no one anticipated a quarter of a century ago.

The Justice Department has resisted the changes. The associate deputy attorney general, James Baker, urged the committee last year to consider the adverse impact on criminal and national security investigations if a warrant were the only means for law enforcement officials to obtain emails and other digital files.

But setting the bar higher doesn't prevent law enforcement agencies from doing their jobs, according to current and former prosecutors, judges and attorneys who specialize in privacy issues. Federal law enforcement authorities in four Midwestern and Southern states have been working with the more demanding warrant requirement since 2010 after an appeals court ruled warrantless access to emails was unconstitutional. To get a warrant, a judge must have proof of probable cause that a crime is being committed.

"I don't see anything (in the Senate bill) that's going to seriously concern law enforcement in terms of our ability to request warrants and to get the contents of the material that we need," said Joseph Cassilly, the state's attorney in Harford County, Md., and a former president of the National District Attorneys Association. "Since you've already got to get warrants for the stuff that's less than 180 days, it's obviously not an insurmountable standard."

Nor does the legislation weaken other methods used by law enforcement for collecting electronic information. A subpoena signed by a federal prosecutor — not a judge — will continue to be sufficient for obtaining routing data from third-party Internet providers that can identify the sender of an email and the location where the message was sent.

Police also can use what is known as a "D order" to get the "to" and "from" addresses of an email, but not the contents. These orders must be issued by a judge, but the agency seeking one need only show there is reasonable suspicion of a crime — a lower legal standard than probable cause.

In a Nov. 21 letter to Leahy, 30 former federal and state prosecutors and judges said the bill would provide "a much needed judicial check on when the government can access our private digital information." Concerns that the bill would keep law enforcement from acting quickly during emergencies are unfounded, they added, because the Senate bill does not change a provision in the existing law that compels third-party providers to give the government information in situations where lives are at risk or children are being exploited or abused.

Digital Due Process, a wide-ranging coalition that includes Google, Microsoft and Twitter, as well as the American Civil Liberties Union and Grover Norquist's Americans for Tax Reform, has mounted a public relations campaign supporting the Senate bill. The coalition says updating the law will clear the "murky legal landscape" for companies and consumers alike and provide the proper safeguards for the vast amounts of information stored in server farms.

There's money at stake, too. The global market for cloud computing via the Internet is estimated to be $240 billion by 2020. But the Business Software Alliance, a coalition member that represents Apple, Intel and Microsoft, said U.S. cloud providers are at a disadvantage unless online privacy and security laws are changed. If consumers aren't sure their information is being properly protected on the remote, networked computer servers that make up the cloud, they'll take their business elsewhere.

Use of the law has been interpreted inconsistently by the courts, further fuel for those pushing for an overhaul. In a 2010 decision, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati ruled that an Ohio businessman's constitutional rights were violated when federal investigators obtained thousands of his emails without warrants. Now investigators in states covered by the 6th Circuit — Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky and Tennessee — must obtain warrants for all emails. But that's not the law in other federal circuits.

In the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers California, Washington, Oregon and six other Western states, judges ruled that a search warrant was required for both opened and unopened email, but only if left on a server for less than 180 days. The Justice Department has argued that a search warrant is required for unopened email left on a server for less than 180 days, but not for opened email less than 180 days old.

The decisions mean different rules apply depending where an investigation begins. How should emails be treated if a case starts in Pennsylvania and the messages are stored on a server in California, the hub for Google, Yahoo and other major Internet businesses?

"It's very confusing," said Hanni Fakhoury, a staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation in San Francisco. "Law enforcement will never admit this, but a uniform search warrant standard is easier for them."

___

Online:

Digital Due Process: http://tinyurl.com/yce79za


View the original article here

Read Post | comentarii

Will poll watchers help or hinder voting in the elections?

vineri, 2 noiembrie 2012

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - In some areas, they are becoming as much a part of elections as voters and precinct workers: poll watchers, the sometimes unofficial monitors who go to polling places with the idea of stopping fraudulent voting.

Poll watchers come in all political stripes - conservative Republicans, liberal Democrats, anti-fraud groups, labor unions and even international organizations.

With the presidential race between Democrat Barack Obama and Republican Mitt Romney extremely close, some groups are looking to poll monitors to ensure a fair election on Tuesday.

But some voting-rights advocates and others are questioning whether such monitors could become an intimidating presence that leads some people - namely minorities and the elderly - not to vote, and slows down the voting process for others.

Some of the observers are credentialed by local governments to monitor the election from inside polling sites and will be allowed to challenge the right of people to vote. Some are lawyers representing the presidential campaigns and their parties, looking out for any irregularities that could be cited in a legal challenge of election results.

Many more poll watchers are likely be outside voting precincts - possibly in large numbers - and could scare off some potential voters, civil-rights advocates say.

"You can be just as harmful outside as inside by creating disruptions," said Eric Marshall, of the Lawyers Committee on Civil Rights Under Law. "We shouldn't be having bullies creating disruptions or intimidating voters at the polling place."

Much of this kind of criticism has focused on conservative groups such as True the Vote, which says it is mobilizing up to 1 million volunteers to monitor polling places.

Catherine Engelbrecht, founder of the group, disputed the notion that monitors will intimidate voters. She echoed the sentiments of Republicans who have said that questionable voter registration efforts in heavily Democratic areas have made it increasingly necessary to monitor for potential voting fraud.

Engelbrecht said the group wants to safeguard the election from fraud by making sure that only legal citizens can vote and dead people are removed from voting rolls.

"We do know that each and every (monitor) is making a huge difference, and we are ... hopefully doing a better job of safeguarding the process," Engelbrecht said.

Whatever they think of poll watchers, both sides in the election want to make sure their supporters turn out to vote, and that voter fraud - which is rare, elections officials say - does not create an advantage for the other side.

States have different rules on who is allowed inside a polling area to monitor elections. Each party usually appoints as many poll watchers as each state allows - each political party and each candidate can have one watcher in each polling room in Florida, for example - and they are credentialed to observe the election from inside the poll site.

In some states a poll watcher, described as a "challenger" in some state laws, can contest whether a voter is eligible to vote or has already voted.

The practice of allowing people who may have received only basic training as poll watchers before Election Day to question a voter's eligibility concerns some legal analysts and others who say the monitors' activity could deny some people their right to vote by slowing down the process so much that some people get frustrated and leave before voting.

"We should leave determining who is eligible to vote to the professionals at the polling place," said Marshall, who manages the Election Protection coalition, a nonpartisan group of more than 100 community and legal organizations. It has a telephone hotline (1-866-OUR-VOTE) that is collecting tips on alleged voter intimidation before and on Election Day.

Democrats and rights groups said poll watchers in some states have been trained by partisan groups that want to prevent their political foes from voting, and that many of the efforts against voter fraud are really attempts to curb voting among minorities and others who tend to vote for Democrats.

They cite groups such as True the Vote, which has held training courses across the nation. On Tuesday, the group's monitoring program will include poll watchers who are credentialed to work inside polling sites as well as others who will stand outside.

Groups such as the AFL-CIO, the largest U.S. labor federation, which is part of Election Protection coalition, have said they are worried that large numbers of True the Vote volunteers outside a polling site could drive away some voters.

Election law specialist Rick Hasen was not so sure.

He said there were typically many more Republican poll watchers in Democratic areas than the opposite. But he questioned whether they had any impact on voting.

"A lot of these end up being more bark than bite," Hasen said. "My guess is there's going to be a lot less of this than some people are forecasting."

'MISINFORMATION' IN TRAINING

The training of some poll watchers has come under scrutiny since September, when a secretly recorded training session for Republican poll watchers in New Mexico became public.

The video, recorded and published by a liberal-leaning group called ProgressNowNM, showed a Republican Party leader telling monitors voters in New Mexico must present photo identification and may not use interpreters while voting, both of which are incorrect. The state's attorney general is investigating.

A similar training course sparked criticism in Wisconsin.

The Obama campaign's chief counsel, Robert Bauer, sent a letter to Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen, asking him to investigate the Romney campaign's training of poll monitors.

Bauer's letter cited a training manual for Republican poll watchers - obtained by the liberal group Think Progress - that misstates the types of documents acceptable to prove residency. The manual, which Think Progress posted on the Internet, also incorrectly states that an assistant helping a handicapped voter needs to have proof of residency.

In his letter, Bauer questioned why Wisconsin's Republican Party would tell poll watchers to identify themselves as a "concerned observer" on Election Day, rather than as a representative of the Republican Party.

"The misinformation communicated to poll watchers, the intent and effect of which is to mislead voters, cannot be dismissed as an isolated example of this tactic," Bauer wrote.

Romney officials called Bauer's letter a "transparently desperate political stunt" and said they stand by the accuracy of the training materials.

A spokesman for Wisconsin's Government Accountability Board told NBC News it objected to the training handbook and would raise the issue with the Romney campaign.

Think Progress also posted a Republican training video from Iowa that tells poll watchers to alert the Republican Party's legal team if they see a voter who is allowed to vote without an ID. But there is no voter ID requirement in Iowa.

The Iowa Secretary of State's Office said it had contacted the state director of the Romney campaign and made this clear.

STATES COOL TO INTERNATIONAL MONITORS

Besides the U.S. groups vying for attention and access to polling sites, groups of international election observers will also be at polling places on Tuesday.

The human rights office of the Vienna-based Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OCSE) is sending 44 observers who will be in the four states with the largest number of Electoral College votes - California, Florida, New York and Texas. It also has a team of 13 analysts based in Washington.

In addition, about 100 parliamentarians from OSCE's 56 member nations will observe the election.

The group has run into resistance in Texas, Ohio and Iowa, where state officials have balked at allowing OSCE monitors access to polling places.

Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott, a Republican, has warned U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton that OSCE monitors are not above Texas law. In a separate letter to the OSCE, Abbott warned that failure to follow state law at voting precincts could subject the monitors to criminal prosecution.

A spokesman of the OSCE's human rights arm, Thomas Ryder, said observers would obey all state laws - including those that prevent them from coming within a certain distance of the polls.

(Editing by David Lindsey and David Brunnstrom)


View the original article here

Read Post | comentarii

Resource

Followers

 

Themes Design by Capricon Vision | Published by Templates | Powered by Blogger.com
Copyright © 2011 Politics - Some Rights Reserved